Buyer's guide
Skid steer vs. compact track loader in Montana
The wheels-or-tracks question is the most common one we hear, and the honest answer is that it depends on your ground and your work. Here is how to decide, with the trade-offs that actually matter across a Montana winter and a Montana job site.
Available now in Billings
Current inventory
The short version
A wheeled skid steer is usually the better choice for hard surfaces, concrete, gravel yards, snow on pavement and jobs where you move quickly between short tasks. A compact track loader shines on soft ground, mud, snow, ranch dirt and slopes where flotation and traction keep you working when a wheeled machine would spin or sink. Many buyers who work year-round on mixed ground lean toward tracks, and accept the higher undercarriage cost as the price of not getting stuck.
Traction and flotation
Tracks spread the machine's weight over a much larger footprint, which is why a track loader floats on soft or wet ground and leaves less rutting on turf. On snow and mud, that traction difference is dramatic. A wheeled skid steer can still work in these conditions with the right tires and technique, but it reaches its limit sooner. If you have ever been stuck in a spring field or a snowed-in lot, the track advantage is easy to feel.
Cost of ownership: tires vs. undercarriage
This is the trade-off that surprises people. Skid steer tires are relatively cheap to replace and you can do it yourself. A track loader's undercarriage, meaning tracks, rollers, sprockets and idlers, costs more to service and replace, and wear accelerates on abrasive surfaces like concrete and gravel. If you run mostly on hard, abrasive surfaces, tracks wear fast and a wheeled machine may cost you less over time.
Weight, transport and site access
Compact track loaders generally weigh more than comparable skid steers, which affects the trailer and truck you need to haul them and how they behave on soft driveways or finished surfaces. If you tow between sites often, check the operating weight against your trailer rating. On tight urban sites, both machine types turn in place, but the track machine's added flotation can be the difference on a muddy residential lot.
How to decide for your work
Write down where you actually work most of the year. Mostly pavement, gravel and snow removal on hard surfaces points to a wheeled skid steer. Mostly dirt, mud, turf, ranch ground and winter fieldwork points to a compact track loader. Then match rated operating capacity and hydraulic flow to your attachments. Current wheeled and tracked machines are shown above, and Chris can talk through which fits your ground before you commit.
Common questions
Before you buy
Is a compact track loader better than a skid steer?
Neither is universally better. Tracks win on soft ground and traction; wheels win on hard surfaces and lower undercarriage cost. The right pick depends on your ground.
Do track loaders cost more to maintain?
Generally yes. The undercarriage is more expensive to service than tires and wears faster on abrasive surfaces like concrete and gravel.
Which is better for snow?
For snow on soft ground, tracks give better traction. For plowing snow on pavement, a wheeled skid steer is often more practical and cheaper to run.
Which is heavier to haul?
Compact track loaders are usually heavier than comparable skid steers, so confirm your trailer and truck ratings before buying.
Can I run the same attachments on both?
Usually yes, if the coupler and hydraulic flow match. Confirm standard versus high flow for powered attachments.
One owner, direct answers
Ask Chris about the machine.
Talk with the person who selected and inspected the inventory.